2027 Benefits Renewal & Open Enrollment Guide
A Guide for Leaders and HR Teams. Best practices for reviewing your renewal and running open enrollment.
The Numbers
14%: Typical Increase Insurance Companies Are Pushing For. Health insurance companies are pushing for a median 14% rate increase for small businesses in 2027, based on proposed rates from 295 of them for plans that generally cover businesses with 50 or fewer employees. Most (59%) are pushing for somewhere between 10% and 20%. Source: Peterson-KFF Health System Tracker, rate requests from 295 insurance companies, August 2026.
9.5%: Projected Rise in Employer Healthcare Costs. As Kathryn Mayer reported for SHRM, Aon projects a 9.5% jump before employers take steps to manage costs, to an average of more than $19,000 per employee. That would be the fourth year in a row of near-double-digit increases. Source: SHRM, reporting Aon’s survey of 1,100+ U.S. employers, August 2026.
8.2%: Expected Rise in Cost per Employee. Marsh expects employer health benefit cost per employee to rise 8.2% in 2027, “the highest increase since 2003.” Source: Marsh, preliminary survey of 1,800+ employers, August 2026.
Four Steps from Renewal to January
Step 1: Before You Sign the Renewal
- Look at which benefits employees actually use, from each medical plan to dental, vision and the Employee Assistance Program (EAP).
- Ask your broker what each option will cost the company and what it will cost employees each paycheck.
- Some lower-priced quotes are for level-funded plans, where the company takes on part of the cost of claims. Ask your broker what protections you'd give up compared with a traditional insurance plan.
Step 2: Communicate Early
- Tell employees what's changing, why it's changing and what it will cost them each month.
- Put the plans side by side with costs employees know, like an office visit or a prescription.
- Make sure managers have support, since employees usually bring their first questions to them.
Step 3: Run Open Enrollment
- Set clear dates and send reminders at the start, the middle and the last few days.
- Schedule sessions where you walk through the changes and employees can ask questions.
- Run a passive enrollment, where employees keep their current plans unless they make a change. Only run an active enrollment, where everyone has to choose again, when it's necessary.
- Include the Summary of Benefits and Coverage (SBC) with your open enrollment materials.
Step 4: After Enrollment Closes
- Check each employee's choices against their payroll deductions before the first paycheck of the year.
- Make sure the enrollment updates sent to each insurance company went through and none of them failed.
- Send each employee a confirmation of what they chose.
- Remind employees that their choices stay in place for the year unless they have a major life change, like marriage, a new baby or losing other coverage.
Watch For: What's driving your costs.
Before you raise deductibles or move more of the cost to employees, look at what's driving the increase. These are some of the most common causes and what you can do about each.
- High Claims: When your rates are based on your own claims, a few large claims can drive up the whole renewal. Encourage preventive care, like hosting a flu shot clinic or reminding employees to book their annual checkup. Most plans cover an annual checkup at no cost when employees see an in-network doctor.
- ER Visits for Non-Emergencies: An ER visit for something an urgent care clinic could handle costs employees and the plan much more. Show employees where the nearest urgent care clinics are, partner with local clinics if they're available, or even raise the ER deductible.
- Prescription Costs: Ask your broker how much of your spending goes to prescriptions, and whether generic drugs or mail order could lower what employees pay.
2027 Limits to Update
- HSA: $4,500 for one person, $9,000 for a family. To pair with a Health Savings Account (HSA), a plan's deductible must be at least $1,750 for one person or $3,500 for a family. (IRS Rev. Proc. 2026-24)
- Health FSA: $3,500 per employee, up to $700 can roll over. The most an employee can set aside from pay for a health Flexible Spending Account (FSA). Plans that allow it can roll up to $700 into the next year. (IRS Rev. Proc. 2026-35)
- ACA Affordability: 10.22%. If you have 50 or more full-time employees (part-time hours count toward that), coverage is affordable under the ACA when an employee's share for the lowest-cost, employee-only option is no more than 10.22% of household income. (IRS Rev. Proc. 2026-26)
Need help sorting through your options or finding cost savings?
At Surge People Partners, we work with HR teams and business owners to compare renewal options with their broker, plan benefits changes and explain those changes to employees in plain language.
Sources
- Peterson-KFF Health System Tracker, “How much and why premiums are going up for small businesses in 2027,” August 6, 2026
- Kathryn Mayer, “Employers Face 9.5% Healthcare Cost Increase in 2027,” SHRM, August 21, 2026 (Aon survey of 1,100+ U.S. employers)
- Marsh, preliminary 2027 health benefit cost survey of 1,800+ employers, August 31, 2026
- IRS Rev. Proc. 2026-24 (HSA), 2026-35 (health FSA) and 2026-26 (ACA affordability)