TL;DR
Most workforce decisions right now are judgment calls, not rules. Start by separating what's truly black and white (the law, safety, what you've put in writing) from what's gray. Then get specific about the gray: name what you know and what you don't, ask what the decision looks like in six months, make the best call you can, and set a date to revisit it. The most common mistake we see is cutting headcount too deep.
Founders and executives keep asking for black-and-white answers. Right now, almost everything is gray.
Should we hire or hold? Do we backfill this role or spread it across the team? Can we cut costs without losing our best people? Leaders want a clear yes or no, and that makes sense. Clear answers are easier to act on, easier to explain to a board, and easier to live with.
The trouble is that this year doesn't offer many clear answers.
The data is pointing in two directions at once
KPMG's 2026 U.S. CEO Outlook surveyed 400 U.S. CEOs. 89% expect to grow headcount over the next three years. In the same survey, 53% said they're planning workforce reductions in some areas. The same leaders are planning to grow and to cut at the same time.
Small and midsize companies are feeling a similar squeeze. In the Q3 2026 Vistage CEO Confidence Index, CEO confidence dropped for the third quarter in a row. While 62% of those CEOs expect higher revenue next year, only 47% expect higher profit, as health care, insurance, interest and energy costs keep climbing.
When growth and cost pressure show up together, workforce decisions stop being simple. That's where most of our conversations with leadership teams start.
Our first answer is usually "Tell me more"
When a founder or executive asks us for a yes or no, our first response is usually a question: "Tell me more," or "Let's talk about it."
That isn't a way to avoid the answer. Most workforce decisions depend on things that aren't visible in the first question: why the role exists, who else would carry the load, what the business needs over the next two quarters, and what has already been promised to employees. A good answer comes from understanding those things first.
From there, we walk leaders through four steps.
Step 1Separate what's truly black and white from what's gray
Some things aren't judgment calls, and treating them like one creates real risk. These are the black-and-white pieces:
- The law: wage and hour rules, leave protections, discrimination and retaliation protections, and how workers are classified
- Safety
- What you've already put in writing: offer letters, contracts, your handbook and your own policies
Everything else is usually a judgment call. Knowing which is which keeps leaders from spending energy debating the fixed pieces and from treating the risky pieces casually.
"We're an at-will state" doesn't settle it
This is the one we hear most often from founders and new executives, including many of our clients in Southern states. At-will employment means you generally don't need a reason to end someone's employment. It doesn't protect you if the real reason looks discriminatory or retaliatory, if it goes against a contract or your own written policies, or if it breaks another law.
In practice, that means every employment decision still needs to be defensible. Before acting, leaders should be able to explain the business reason clearly, show that it's applied consistently, and point to the documentation that supports it.
Step 2Get specific about the gray
For a true judgment call, we help leaders get specific about three things:
- What we know today
- What we don't know yet, and when we'll find out
- What would change the decision
We also ask who needs to weigh in. A decision about cutting a role affects finance, operations and the managers who will absorb the load, so they should be part of it.
Step 3Ask what it looks like in six months
The question we ask before almost every workforce decision is simple:
What does this look like in six months, and does it get us where we need to be?
It pulls the conversation past this quarter's numbers. A cut that saves money in November can create a staffing gap in March, a missed customer commitment in April, or a resignation from a high performer who has been covering two jobs since the cut.
Step 4Make the call, write down why, and set a date to revisit it
Waiting for certainty usually means waiting too long. Make the best decision you can with the information you have, write down the reasoning and the assumptions behind it, and set a date to revisit it. If the assumptions change, the decision can change too, and everyone knows why.
Where we see it go wrong most: cutting too deep
The mistake we see most often is cutting headcount too deep.
It usually follows the same pattern. The cut leaves gaps, and the remaining team gets stretched too thin. Morale drops, work-life balance suffers, and engagement goes down. The high performers, who have the most options, are often the first to leave. Within months, the company is trying to rehire the people it laid off, replace the high performers who left, or both. And anyone new needs time to get up to speed.
The research lines up with what we see. Vistage notes that decades of research have found layoffs rarely deliver the gains leaders expect. Orgvue found that 32% of organizations that made layoffs linked to AI have since had to bring staff back. And in a Leadership IQ study of more than 4,000 employees who kept their jobs after a layoff, 74% said their own productivity had declined since the layoff.
None of this means a reduction is never the right decision. Sometimes it is. It means the full cost belongs in the decision: the workload on the people who stay, the risk of losing your strongest performers, and the cost and time of rehiring later.
The tough decisions leaders are facing right now
Here are the decisions we're helping leadership teams think through most often, with the questions we ask before each one.
Hire or hold
- What breaks if this role stays open for another quarter?
- Is the need ongoing, or is it a project with an end date?
- Could interim or project support cover it while demand becomes clearer?
Backfill or absorb the role
- Who would absorb these responsibilities, and what would they stop doing?
- How long can the team realistically carry the extra load?
- Is this a chance to redesign the role instead of replacing it as it was?
Cutting costs without losing your best people
- Have we looked at every other cost lever first?
- Who are the people we can't afford to lose, and do they know it?
- What would it cost to replace them, including time to get someone new up to speed?
Restructuring
- What problem is the new structure solving?
- Which managers will carry the change, and are they ready for it?
- How and when will we explain it to the team?
Changing benefits
Benefits are on a lot of agendas this year. In the Vistage survey, 74% of CEOs expect health care costs to rise at least 6% next year, and 71% plan to get competitive bids on their health plan.
- What do employees value most in the current plan?
- How would a change affect recruiting and retention for hard-to-fill roles?
- What notice do employees need, and what do we need to communicate?
The gray isn't going away
Uncertainty has become the normal operating environment. Writing in Harvard Business Review, Simone Stolzoff points out that the five highest readings of global economic policy uncertainty since tracking began in the 1980s have all come in the past five years.
That means leaders will keep facing decisions without every answer in front of them. The goal is to make those decisions with clear eyes: knowing what's fixed, being honest about what's uncertain, and thinking past the next quarter.
How Surge People Partners helps
Surge People Partners is an HR Technology & Services Firm. Our team of HR executives supports founders and leadership teams through decisions like these, from when to hire or hold to how to restructure while keeping your best people. We support HR teams of one through fully staffed departments, whether it's a quick turn project or ongoing HR executive and operational support.
Download the one-page guide: Black, White or Gray? (PDF)Frequently Asked Questions
Does at-will employment mean I can let someone go without risk?
No. At-will employment generally means you don't need a reason to end employment, but it doesn't protect a decision that is discriminatory, retaliatory, against a contract or your written policies, or otherwise unlawful. Employment decisions still need a clear business reason, consistent treatment and documentation.
How do I decide whether to backfill a role or spread the responsibilities across the team?
Start with who would absorb the responsibilities, what they would stop doing, and how long they can realistically carry the extra load. Then ask what the decision looks like in six months. If the team will be stretched past that point, backfilling or bringing in interim support is usually the better choice.
What's the biggest mistake companies make when cutting costs?
Cutting headcount too deep. It stretches the remaining team, lowers morale and engagement, and pushes high performers out, which often leads to costly rehiring later. Look at other cost levers first, and include the cost of replacing key people in the decision.
How often should leaders revisit a workforce decision?
Set a review date when you make the decision, typically within one or two quarters. Write down the assumptions behind it, and revisit sooner if those assumptions change.
Facing a tough workforce decision?
We help founders and leadership teams decide whether to hire now or wait, whether to replace someone who left, and how to restructure while keeping your best people.
Written by
Natalie Mueller, MBA, SPHR/SHRM-SCP
Natalie is the founder of Surge People Partners and has 20+ years of executive HR experience across healthcare, hospitality, senior living, and high-growth startups.